Skip to content

Writing

Water, Smoke, and Words: Patricia Vázquez Gómez's Ode to Indigenous Language

Exhibition review, Oregon Artswatch, April 1

2025

As an Irish immigrant, living with my multilingual family in a culturally diverse Southeast neighborhood, I am constantly aware of the daily tangle of languages surrounding us. Historically some 25-35 native languages were spoken in Oregon prior to European settlers, of which nine are still spoken fluently today. Portland’s official website lists a further fifteen dominant non-English languages of local immigrants in which the city is committed to communicate, when necessary, to support community members. Unfortunately, the endangered 90% of the world’s 7,000+ languages are not helped by such well-meaning efforts. Among the 715+ indigenous languages spoken in South and Central America, many of which are present among Portland’s immigrant communities, only Spanish makes the city’s list. 

Minority immigrant languages often disappear after one generation, according to artist Patricia Vázquez Gómez, whose new immersive video installation at Portland Institute of Contemporary Art (PICA) explores the relationship between a group of Mayan youth in her home neighborhood in NE Portland with their mother tongue, maayat’aan. This Maya Peninsular/Yucatec Mayan spoken by the preteens – but not fluently– is one of sixty-eight Indigenous living languages in present-day Mexico.

At PICA, viewers are offered beanbags to sit or lie on (if they are able), immersing themselves in the unfolding sounds and images of five surrounding and overhead cinematic screens that collectively make up ja’/buuts’/t’aan: Agua/Humo/Palabra (Water/Smoke/Word). The film begins quietly with an overhead projection of a nocturnal water surface, a glimmer of light bringing the landscape into visibility. The movements of a small, winged insect send out ripples. As the light increases, rocks can be seen at the bottom of a ts’ono’ot– a rocky sinkhole filled with groundwater, that is a common natural phenomenon in the Yucatán municipalities of Maní and Dzan, where Gómez traveled to film source locations of the language.

The near silence of the opening video sequence is broken by the whispered chanting of young voices repeating the word ja’, ja’, ja’ (the maayat’aan for water). The vocal layering and repetition of words form a cacophony that overlays a background sound of water drops as the overhead film projection shows the caverns surrounding the stony rock pools. A valuable source of water in a region with no lakes or rivers, the ts’ono’ot pools hold sacred significance, representing an entrance to the underworld. 

Lying on my back, I watch the filmic play of light on the water and listen as the language is chanted and becomes prayer-like, as if it’s speaking to or emerging from the landscape. No translation is given beyond the work’s title and the meaning of many words is unintelligible to those who do not understand maayat’aan. But the experience of listening to the sounds of the language allows it to go deeper under the skin than words used as mere codes for communication.

This is the opening of a three-part 35-minute video sequence that engages in turn with ja’ (water), buuts’ (smoke) and t’aan (words). In the second sequence, we hear a loud wind-like whispering as the surrounding four screens show images of smoke rising from stony, blackened land. Trees and rocks are panned over, and one word is being repeated so many times that I start to sing along to it too. The camera shows a fire burning in a yard, the literal source of some of the smoke, and a new word is repeated more slowly, the sound of individual youth’s voices becoming intelligible. Each child chants in their own singular pitch, reciting a longer text against a vista of burning ash. 

The exhibition text notes that one of the historical anchors for this sequence was the knowledge that many of the youths’ families came from the Yucatán town of Manì, the site of an Inquisition-led burning of 5,000 Mayan idols, sacred objects, and library archive of precious texts. This culminated in a period of torture and killing of local Mayans who refused to convert to Catholicism. Vázquez Gómez was struck by the uncanny presence of fires in everyday life in the region, often a mere burning of garbage but her painterly film vignettes evocatively bridge this time gap. 

Against these fire scenes, the repeated whispering of a word gets louder and louder like a protest chant or a school language learning exercise. The rhythm lends a sense of urgency and the screens black out momentarily before a close-up scene of burning, as the children whisper buuts’, buuts’, buuts’, the Yucatan Mayan word for smoke. The language being spoken is clearly not English or any European language. The clicking sound in some tones brings to my mind Indigenous Oregonian languages like Chinuk Wawa but there are many sounds that exceed recognition or comparison. According to Vázquez Gómez, the maayat’aan language contains 25 vowel sounds alone, five times as many as the English language.  

In the third video sequence, the nine young people are seen from overhead, lying on the stubbled dried-out summer grass. The scene appears at first to be filmed in a field but as the camera zooms out, one can see the metal fences and red brick building of a typical Portland schoolyard. This scene is overlaid with the sound of bees buzzing in their hive. There is a glimpse of their busy labor before the camera cuts to close-ups of two preteens, whispering into the ear of each other in Telephone game-like fashion. Watching this scene, it is poetically tangible that language transfer is a person-to-person act, a labor of love, carried by friends and families as much or more than any school or institutional system. This is certainly the case for these youth whose only social source of this language is their families and neighbors.

This reality of a neighborhood acting as a container for a language partly inspired Vázquez Gómez’s new work, along with her personal life experience as a Spanish speaker from Mexico, whose ancestors likely spoke an indigenous language to which she has no access. Growing up, and feeling this lack, she later gravitated toward language as material for artistic research and social engagement. Her recent attempts to learn maayat’aan reflects her long-term wish to learn an indigenous language, yet she acknowledges that she is far from fluent. 

Vázquez Gómez is neither a linguist or an anthropologist with skills associated with language revival, nor is this her primary interest. Rather, her background includes working with immigrant and labor rights movements and coming in contact with many indigenous speakers from Mexico and Guatemala. It was her maayat’aan-speaking neighbors and subsequent awareness that alerted her to how many indigenous speakers there were in her locale in NE Portland which led Vázquez Gómez to foreground the predicament of this Mayan language. 

Watching the young people in ja’/buuts’/t’aan, it is palpable that the weight of responsibility for the survival of their language rests on their small shoulders. Most have never learned to read or write in the language, a situation addressed in “Tene’kin Tanik Maaya: I speak Mayan” (2022), a previous iteration of this long-term project by Vázquez Gómez, in which she created graphic works, T-shirts, and totes with the young people who wanted to visualize their language. 

The PICA installation is the artist’s first video and audio-based work. She chose to approach the language as sound in this work so that any viewer or listener can relate to it and feel it in their body, an intuitive and potentially emotional encounter. It is wonderful to see Portland Institute for Contemporary Art providing the necessary resources for a local artist to understand this scale of work in a new medium. This investment has paid off in the form of a memorable exhibition that will leave viewers with food for thought about other lived realities among Portland’s inhabitants, about family and ancestors, future descendants, and what is at stake in the global disappearance of languages worldwide. 

In a closing video vignette, the youths crouch on the earth with their eyes closed, ear to the ground, as if listening for it to speak back. They may be far from the Yucatán town of Manì but their keen sense of listening also invokes the unheard and untold stories of the stewards of this land. Oregon’s ceded and unceded territories hold the Indigenous languages of the Multnomah, Oregon City Tumwater, Watlala, Wasco, Kathlamet, Cowlitz, Clackamas, Bands of Chinook, Tualatin Kalapuya, Molalla, and many other Indigenous peoples in this region. Their histories of displacement, genocide, cultural, linguistic and spiritual suppression resonate with the questions of survival and resilience evoked by Vázquez Gómez’s work. There is pride and joy in the young faces of these Mayan descendants, as they share the language, one by one, reciting texts by contemporary maayat’aan author Wildernain Villegas-Carrillo.

While viewers may not understand the words, the beauty of the language itself and the youths’ commitment to its survival is communicated in ways that do not need translation. This poignant and evocative film closes with the sound of breathing, reminding us that bodies keep languages alive.

Patricia Vázquez Gómez, ja’/buuts’/t’aan: Agua/Humo/Palabra (Water/Smoke/Word) is open at Portland Institute of Contemporary Art (PICA) from March 13th through May 31st 2025. PICA is located at 15 NE Hancock Street. Viewing times and opening hours are available at www.pica.org

Writing

Lucy Cotter is a prolific writer of art criticism, cultural analysis, creative non-fiction, art history, art theory, ficto-theory, poetry, exhibition, dance, performance, and cross-disciplinary texts. She often experiments with the generative relationship between art-making and writing processes, allowing the subject to shape the form of her writing.

She is the author of Reclaiming Artistic Research (Hatje Cantz, 2019, expanded 2nd ed. 2024), a book foregrounding the singular nature of artistic thinking in dialogue with acclaimed artists worldwide. She is a regular contributor to books on contemporary art and culture by academic presses and has published in catalogues and monographs on Haegue Yang, Rabih Mroué, Katarina Zdjelar, Manuela Infante, and Brian O’Doherty, among other artists.

She is the editor of several exhibition catalogues, including Cinema Olanda: Wendelien Van Oldenborgh for the 57th Venice Biennale, and has guest-edited a number of art journals, including MaHKUscript Journal for Arts Research and Third Text. Her art critical writing has appeared in Flash Art, Artforum, Hyperallergic, Oregon Artswatch, CARA, Field Day, and Frieze. Her creative nonfiction and poetry have been published in Typishly, Cirque, The Brooklyn Rail, Sea Wolf and Mousse Magazine, among other journals. She is an alum of Tin House and Corporeal Writing, Portland.

Books

  • Reclaiming Artistic Research: Expanded Second Edition

    Berlin: Hatje Cantz

    Expanding the original book with additional artist dialogues and a new essay, this edition explores the changing stakes of artistic research in a world reckoning with social justice, climate change, and the rise of artificial intelligence through a series of 24 in-depth dialogues with artists worldwide.

    2024
  • Reclaiming Artistic Research

    Berlin: Hatje Cantz

    In twenty conversations with leading artists worldwide, Lucy Cotter maps out an epistemology of artistic creation. She manifests a type of research that is dynamically engaged with other fields, but thinks beyond concepts into bodily and material knowledge that exceeds language, revolutionizing our perception of art from the ground up.

    2019

Books in Progress

Books Chapters & Essays

  • Haegue Yang: Day and Night

    Haegue Yang: The Great Forgetfulness

    Fergal Gaynor, ed.

    Cork: National Sculpture Factory

    forthcoming 2025
    2025
  • Global Engagement and Modalities of Looking: Brian Maguire, Richard Mosse, and Yuri Pattison

    Routledge Companion to Irish Art

    Fionna Barber and Fintan Cullen, eds.

    London: Routledge

    forthcoming 2025
    2025
  • unraveling: practice-led curating

    Companion to Curatorial Futures

    Bridget Crone, Bassam el Baroni, Matthew Poole, eds.

    Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press

    forthcoming 2025
    2025
  • Delegitimizing the Continuum of Violence

    Brian Maguire: The Grand Illusion

    Dublin: The Hugh Lane National Gallery

    2024
  • Theatre as Thinking, Art as Nonknowledge

    Manuela Infante: Estado Vegetal: Performance and Plant-Thinking

    Giovanni Aloi, ed.

    Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press

    2023
  • The Warp and Weft of History

    Kristina Benjocki: The Warp and Weft of History

    Amsterdam: Looiersgracht 60

    2023
  • Fact as Fiction: A Dialogue with Rabih Mroué

    Rabih Mroué: Interviews

    Nadim Samman, ed.

    Berlin: Hatje Cantz

    2023
  • Braiding: Transgenerational Artistic Comradeship

    Katarina Zdjelar (monograph)

    Middlesborough: Institute of Modern Art & Teeside University

    2022
  • (tropisms) away from and towards the thing, it, she

    Natasha Pike (artist's book)

    Dublin: Arts Council

    2022
  • Beyond the Walls of National Identity: The Triangulation of Art Criticism, Curatorial Discourse, and Artistic Practice

    Irish Art 1920–2020: Perspectives on Change

    Yvonne Scott and Christine Kennedy, eds.

    Dublin: Royal Hibernian Academy

    2022
  • Between and Beyond the Dramaturgical

    Fieldings, Sher Doruff, ed.

    Amsterdam: DAS Publishing/University of the Arts.

    2021
  • The Space Beyond Boundaries (On Rosie Heinrich)

    Fieldings, Sher Doruff, ed.

    Amsterdam: DAS Publishing/University of the Arts.

    2021
  • Walking the Wrinkled Plane

    Fieldings, Sher Doruff, ed.

    Amsterdam: DAS Publishing/University of the Arts.

    2021
  • Preparing for Liquefaction

    Fieldings, Sher Doruff, ed.

    Amsterdam: DAS Publishing/University of the Arts.

    2021
  • The Accidental Symbol: Performance as a Conduit

    Fieldings, Sher Doruff, ed.

    Amsterdam: DAS Publishing/University of the Arts.

    2021
  • After a While, Reflectively: Performing an Ecology of Composition Practice

    Fieldings, Sher Doruff, ed.

    Amsterdam: DAS Publishing/University of the Arts.

    2021
  • The Body as a Crease of Knowledge

    Fieldings, Sher Doruff, ed.

    Amsterdam: DAS, University of the Arts

    2021
  • Art Stars and Plasters on the Wounds: Why Have There Been No Great Irish Artists?

    Sources in Irish Art 2: A Reader

    Fintan Cullen and Róisín Kennedy, eds.

    Cork: Cork University Press

    2021
  • Unknowing Culture

    Persistent Traces of Things to Come

    Marjoca de Greef and Anastasija Pandilovska, eds.

    Amsterdam: Sun and Stars

    2020
  • Mercurial States

    e-flux Education

    2019
  • Towards an autonomy of self, towards a community of self

    Katarina Zdjelar: Vladimir

    Lucerne: Centre of Contemporary Art

    2019
  • Cinema Olanda: Toward a Platform, Realized and Anticipated

    Blessing and Transgressing: A Live Institute

    Defne Ayas, ed.

    London: Cornerhouse

    2018
  • Between the White Cube and the White Box: Aspen 5+6

    Brian O Doherty/Patrick Ireland: Word, Image and Institutional Critique, ed. Christa Maria Lerm Hayes. Amsterdam: Valiz

    2017
  • Cinema Olanda: Projecting the Netherlands

    Cinema Olanda: Wendelien van Oldenborgh, ed. Lucy Cotter, Berlin: Hatje Cantz, p. 11–21

    2017
  • Between the White Cube and the White Box: Brian O’Doherty’s Aspen 5+6, An Early Exposition

    The Exposition of Artistic Research: Publishing Art in Academia

    Michael Schwab and Henk Borgdorff, eds.

    Leiden: Leiden University Press.

    2014
  • Close Listening: Katarina Zdjelar’s My lifetime (Malaika)

    Katarina Zdjelar: Of More Than One Voice

    Vitoria-Gasteiz: Artium Basque Museum-Centre of Contemporary Art

    2013
  • 180 Degrees: The University after Artistic Research

    Art Education: A Glossary

    Tom Vandeputte, ed.

    Amsterdam: Sandberg Institute

    2013
  • Libia Olafur: The Future of Hospitality

    Under Deconstruction: Icelandic Pavilion, 54th Venice Biennale

    Ellen Blumenstein, ed.

    Berlin: Sternberg Press

    2011

The above contributions are selected from 2011–2025. A list of selected earlier publications from 2005–2010 is available on request.

Journals

  • Water, Smoke, and Words: Patricia Vázquez Gómez's Ode to Indigenous Language

    Exhibition review, Oregon Artswatch, April 1

    2025
  • The Permanence of Trees

    Flash memoir, Sea Wolf Journal, 6 March

    2025
  • TBA Review: FORCE! an opera in three acts

    Performance review, Oregon Arts Watch

    11 September 2024
    2024
  • St. Louis Girls, 1957

    Poetry, Cirque, Vol 14, no, 2, p. 115

    2024
  • The Ingenious Multiplicity of Brian O’Doherty

    Tribute article, memorial publication,

    The Brooklyn Rail.

    02 May 2023
    2023
  • Empathy and Eros: Ralph Pugay’s The Longest Journey

    Exhibition review, Oregon Arts Watch.

    11 December 2023
    2023
  • The Weft of History: Kristina Benjocki at IKOB, Eupen

    Exhibition review, Metropolis M

    1 June 2022
    2022
  • The Promise of “Opacity”: Takahiro Yamamoto’s Opacity of Performance at Portland Art Museum

    Performance review, Oregon Arts Watch

    24 June 2022
    2022
  • Disintegrating Language: Will Rawls’s “Amphigory”

    Exhibition Review, Oregon Arts Watch.

    23 November 2022
    2022
  • Brian O’ Doherty, Paradigm-Shifting Artist Dies at 94

    Tribute article, Hyperallergic.

    9 November 2022
    2022
  • The Art of Zoom

    Essay, RUUKU Journal for Artistic Research, Vol. 14

    6 August 2020
    2020
  • The Art of Zoom

    Essay: “The Art of Zoom”, republished, In the Pause of an Echo, There May Be A Shadow, online symposium publication.

    2020
  • Mia Habib, ALL – a physical poem of protest

    Performance review, Flash Art

    27 September 2019
    2019
  • An Intimate Dance of Objects: Gordon Hall

    Exhibition review, Mousse Magazine

    11 June 2019
    2019
  • Rob Halverson, Enthusiastic-Remotest-Tree

    Exhibition review, Flash Art

    5 June 2019
    2019
  • The Exhibition after Time and Space: On Mario Garcia Torres’s Survey ‘Illusion brought Me Here’

    Essay, Mousse Magazine

    Spring 2019
    2019
  • Design as Relationality, Aesthetics as Agency

    Essay, Sophie Krier, ed. Issue 4, Field Essays.

    2019
  • Wendelien van Oldenborgh at CA2M, Madrid

    Exhibition Preview, Artforum, Summer edition (print and digital).

    2019
  • Beyond the White Cube: Sixty Years of Brian O’ Doherty’s Letters

    Book review, Frieze.

    25 February 2019
    2019
  • Plants as Other: Manuela Infante’s Estado Vegetal at Portland Institute of Contemporary Art

    Performance Review, Mousse Magazine

    17 May 2019
    2019
  • Becoming the Archive: A Dialogue with Euridice Kala

    MaHKUscript Journal for Fine Art Research, Vol (3), Issue 1.

    2018
  • Reclaiming Artistic Research… First Thoughts

    Essay, MaHKUscript Journal for Fine Art Research, Vol (3), Issue 1, 2018

    2018
  • Knowledge as Production: A Dialogue with Liam Gillick

    MaHKUscript Journal for Fine Art Research, Vol (3), Issue 1

    2018
  • Pockets of Continuity

    Poetry, Typishly, August 27

    2018
  • The Afterlife of the British Museum

    Fiction, Mousse Magazine, 11 July 2018

    2018
  • Writing as Experiment: A Dialogue with Sher Doruff

    MaHKUscript Journal for Fine Art Research, Vol (3), Issue 1, 2018

    2018
  • Black Urban Choreography: NIC Kay’s Pushit!

    Performance Review, Mousse Magazine.

    26 October 2018
    2018
  • Beyond Language: A Dialogue with Falke Pisano

    MaHKUscript Journal for Fine Art Research, Vol (3), Issue 1.

    2018
  • Sound as Knowledge: A Dialogue with Samson Young

    MaHKUscript Journal for Fine Art Research, Vol (3), Issue 1

    2018
  • Research as Play: A Dialogue with Ryan Gander

    MaHKUscript Journal for Fine Art Research, Vol (3), Issue 1

    2018

The above contributions are selected from 2018–2025 only. A list of selected earlier publications from 2003–2017 is available on request.

The keys of a computer are not entirely different than those of a piano. Fingers moving across a plane, producing sounds that are spoken or read. Tracing how material and embodied sensibilities can undermine the imposition of language; how words can act as placeholders for emerging subject positions and worldmaking. Embraced as a medium, writing aligns itself with the internal logic of art making.